XR68UZ XR68UZ Donating Members 732 Member For: 18y 11m 30d Location: Sydney Posted 15/10/08 04:27 AM Share Posted 15/10/08 04:27 AM hey guys, its been 3 years now since I had my ba auto T. since then ive gone through an s15 and am currently driving a rex, however im looking at getting into a new car around march next year.the cars on my short list atm are the VW Golf GTI (DSG - with staff discount) and the FG XR6T (ZF). Im currently in a 2005 rex which I hope to offload by this time.I estimate a budget of 50k max but would prefer to spend closer to the 45 mark.what are your opinions on the new FG. im hoping to get the lux pack fitted as well and drive the car home for about 48k with the zf (how much have you been picking up your cars for?)Things important to me in a car are : build quality, fuel economy, low end power (for city driving). ive owned a tuned T before so I know its going to be heavier on fuel than the gti, but the gti is also a lot smaller.thanks guys,Johnp.s. anyone owned both a gti and an fg? I work with vw so I know pretty much everythign about the gti, but would like to hear from someone who drives one on a daily basis Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
uniqsouljah Member 113 Member For: 16y 4m 5d Gender: Male Location: caroline springs, melb Posted 15/10/08 07:58 AM Share Posted 15/10/08 07:58 AM I got my fg with lux pack, tech pack, dash colour, zf6, spare alloy + scuffs and dash mat for 45k drive-away in melb. I got quoted around 53k + onroads for all of that from another dealer I laughed in there face lol coz I knew I could get it cheaper if I looked around more.though my fg is practically a weekender I do drive it around the city frequently and I get around 11.6/100 city driving. which isnt too bad I reckon, the power is certainly there when you want it, almost non stop boost its freaking awesome. as for build quality, I havent found/experienced anything wrong with my fg at all yet ive only clocked up 1660kms so its probably expected to not find anything yet. id go for the fg superior car, but if your on a budget look into the long run of the costs of running such a car, probably end up going the GTI cause of the petrol and probably maintenance cost in the future will be cheaper for the GTI rather than the FG(since its gona be swapped to a v6, the I6 parts are probably gona be more expensive for it if anything go's wrong)...your choice, but id go the T just for the thrill of owning a great car Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
XR68UZ XR68UZ Donating Members 732 Member For: 18y 11m 30d Location: Sydney Posted 15/10/08 08:21 AM Author Share Posted 15/10/08 08:21 AM wow 45 on the road is an amazing price optioned up like that. I work for vw so with staffies I can pick up a 3dr gti with leather and roof for around that money too. but I cant justify spending so much on a tiny car like that. switching to a v6 huh? anyone know reasons behidn the move?gti servicing costs are roughly 2500 over 4 years but its only serviced once a year/every 15 000kms. ill be doing my own oil changes inbetween services regardless of which I choose though. anyone know the service costs on an xr?I loved the power of my xr, and I only realised what a great car it was till after I got rid of it. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
XR68UZ XR68UZ Donating Members 732 Member For: 18y 11m 30d Location: Sydney Posted 15/10/08 08:39 AM Author Share Posted 15/10/08 08:39 AM and then theres the argument for FG xr6 vs BF2 F6.similar price range. what would you take? are the new FG's 6T the same body as the new FG F6? (I.e. can you simple change bumper bars on them? lol) Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Benny Member 1,869 Member For: 21y 5m 2d Gender: Male Location: Newcastle Posted 15/10/08 08:55 AM Share Posted 15/10/08 08:55 AM I too looked at the GTI and R32 before buying my FG. I think the Golf would be a good little performer around the city with great economy and reasonable resale. But for me the deciding factors were the FG XR6T has bulk power compaired to the Golf and plenty more room to fit people in and interior options. Disadvantages for the XR is more fuel costs, bad resale and maybe a little less build quality, not that I've had any issues with mine so far.Oh and one more advantage for the FG is 300rwkw with injectors and a tune. Gotta be happy with that.Benny Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
uniqsouljah Member 113 Member For: 16y 4m 5d Gender: Male Location: caroline springs, melb Posted 15/10/08 12:23 PM Share Posted 15/10/08 12:23 PM and then theres the argument for FG xr6 vs BF2 F6.similar price range. what would you take? are the new FG's 6T the same body as the new FG F6? (I.e. can you simple change bumper bars on them? lol)for resale value the bf2 phoon will most likely be the best option over the fg in the future, reason being its a FPV. I would still go for the FG, has more power potential and I reckon the design is quite nice but theres HEAPS of people out there that think its gone back to the AU look, though I dont see a resemblance or am I just blind? either way, fg would be the go over the bf2 phoon for me basically coz of power potential/easier user controls/good handling/slicker look. I would also like to know abot the bumper bar change I like the raccoon eyes for some reason :D Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Raging Member 348 Member For: 16y 3m 28d Gender: Male Location: Central Qld Posted 15/10/08 01:37 PM Share Posted 15/10/08 01:37 PM I checked out the GTI before I bought my FG T and thought it was a good little package, however doing mainly highway driving I went for FG. Having had a BA XR8 which I did a few mods on and a BFII Typhoon, I can say that I am really enjoying the FG more than those cars. Nice and practical functionality, got everything I wanted for it and haven't looked back. I loved the Typhoon, but when my wife started a new job she had to start doing 150km a day for work, and that took my leasecar (ML Triton) off me to get me out to my work and back, and the roads to the mine and back aren't real flash, and rather than seeing the Typhoon get bashed around, I sold it.However, if I had the choice again between the BFII Typhoon and the FG XR6T, I think I would go with the FG still. It hasn't got "FPV" written on it, but at the end of the day, a car is what you make it, so do a few minor mods and have it putting out as much power as the FG 'phoon if that's what you are looking for. Getting back to your question, though I haven't done much driving in the GTI, I couldn't really justify spending so much on a little car. Maybe if 95% of my driving was in the city or built up areas I would have considered it, though there is the XR5 Focus to compete with it there... Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
XR68UZ XR68UZ Donating Members 732 Member For: 18y 11m 30d Location: Sydney Posted 15/10/08 09:46 PM Author Share Posted 15/10/08 09:46 PM thanks for the replies guys. the interior of the fg sure does look nicer then the ba/bf. a bf2 phoon would be good just for the namesake of having one. but from the figures and my little research on the fg the xr6t is as quick as the old phoons were!golf gti is a great car too, and probably a lot better on fuel especially in stop start traffic. I think the resale would be better too as the next car I buy I will be holding it for 3 years min. that said the xr6 is probably a more practical car in the long term and something I could easily make feel new again with a few mods.have they fixed the diff clunk problems they were having in the ba's? ill be going auto so that rules the xr5 out. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
XR68UZ XR68UZ Donating Members 732 Member For: 18y 11m 30d Location: Sydney Posted 15/10/08 09:51 PM Author Share Posted 15/10/08 09:51 PM also what do the keys look like now? do they still have 2 separate keys (one for ign one for central locking). that part of the ba sh*t me to death lol Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Raging Member 348 Member For: 16y 3m 28d Gender: Male Location: Central Qld Posted 16/10/08 12:14 AM Share Posted 16/10/08 12:14 AM The FG key is one of the flip out ones, so it's one piece, 1 key Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now