mbjunior99 Member 4,359 Member For: 22y 2m 2d Gender: Male Location: Brisbane Posted 31/03/07 12:00 PM Share Posted 31/03/07 12:00 PM Ok, anyone got some proof? I think hiddeous runs one as well if I'm not mistaken. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
dingah2 Crusty aviator Member 846 Member For: 20y 8m 6d Gender: Male Location: ACT Posted 31/03/07 07:42 PM Share Posted 31/03/07 07:42 PM With reference to the original quation about does a turbo run hotter than an NA the answer is YES.Take your turbo for a spirited bit of driving - not for long, 5 mins will do and then stop in a dark place such as your garage with the lights out, pop the bonnet and enjoy the irridescent glow!'That's heat unique to the operation of your turbo.Dingah Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
JimmyXR6T04 Member 1,299 Member For: 19y 8m 5d Location: Canberra Posted 31/03/07 11:20 PM Share Posted 31/03/07 11:20 PM I dont believe that, thermostats only restrict the water supply to the radiator when the engine starts up from cold helping it to get to full temp quicker. 90% of engine wear occursr when cold due to larger clearances and cold oil not protecting like warm oil. once the engine reaches operating temp, it is fully open and therefore cant make it run cooler than it otherwise would. waste of money... some people believe anything...as I said, in conjunction with edit, and the way it is tuned, the cooler thermostat has helped. Let me explain my situation...I had a mail order tune from XFT, previously, Simon supplied a tune to be installed and "touched" up by Chris from blue power when he was in canberra. This resulted in 250rwkw. Not long after, I decided I wanted more power, so I sent my box back to Simon, and he put in a 300rwkw tune for me. I added bigger injectors, fuel pump, intercooler and cat. Anyways, Simon thought that a cooler thermostat was fitted to my car when he supplied the tune.. but, one was never fitted. Hence, I'd drive around, and even in the middle of winter the thermo fans would come on at 1/4 temp and stay on for the rest of the journey (temp gauge still reached halfway).. this was somewhat concerning so I called Simon and spoke to him, and it was quickly agreed that Chris mustn't have fitted the cooler thermostat on his visit. And Simon had tuned the car to factor this in. Once the cooler thermostat was fitted the thermo fans have been on once or twice, when the outside temp was hot and the car had been turned off for a few mins.. or in spirited driving. Otherwise, in conjunction with edit and the cooler thermostat my car hasn't been near 1/2 way.Hope this clears it up a bit. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
groper Member 611 Member For: 18y 24d Posted 01/04/07 12:36 AM Share Posted 01/04/07 12:36 AM ok, I should point out there could be execptions considering where you live -in a cold climate. im in the northern tropics so it doesnt apply up here as it never gets below about 14 degrees in the middle of a cold winters night. but say your driving along very calmly 60km/h on a cold canberra night, flat road, very light loads etc I suppose the engine temp could drop low enough for the thermostat to kick in and therefore a cooler thermostat would run the engine cooler. otherwise, my first statement still stands.as far as your situations goes, ill take a guess at whats happened. the tune you got was telling the thermo fans to come on at a lower temp, which is good practice IMHO.Then, your original thermostat may have been too hot (they play up all the time and have just changed mine in my au), they easily can make an engine run too hot but they cant make it run cooler unless in a situation I described above. when you changed it out, it fixed the problem and now your running where it should be. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
howitzer85 Member 241 Member For: 18y 5d Gender: Male Location: The marsh... Posted 01/04/07 08:01 AM Share Posted 01/04/07 08:01 AM A colder thermostat will open earlier then the stock one allowing the cooling process to start earlier. Lets say the stock thermostat opens at 80* (not sure what they open at this is just for explanation). Then the engine will only start to be cooled at 80* - when the thermostat opens to allow coolant thru the radiator. If the colder one opens at 70* (again don't know the real numbers, just for explanation) then the cooling process will start when the engine is at 70* - which will keep the engine running cooler.The purpose of the engine running cooler is to allow more advanced timing to be made with less risk of detonationThis is just my understanding correct me if I am wrong. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
groper Member 611 Member For: 18y 24d Posted 01/04/07 08:30 AM Share Posted 01/04/07 08:30 AM yeah your right, but once they have opened, they are open. ie once the engine IS hot, thermostat has no effect.the only factors governing the temp once hot, is airflow, load, and radiator size/effiency. the colder thermostat will just let the motor warm up slower... Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
xrdreaming Lifetime Members 1,693 Member For: 22y 27d Gender: Male Location: Melbourne Posted 01/04/07 11:22 AM Share Posted 01/04/07 11:22 AM That was always my understanding too. Once they are open, they are open, the cooler thermostats are not great for built engines as the forged pistons want to get up to operating temps quickly. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
tab Sucker Moderating Team 32,303 Member For: 20y 10m Gender: Male Location: Brisbane Posted 01/04/07 09:48 PM Share Posted 01/04/07 09:48 PM The cooler thermostat would help your auto get up to temp sooner as well wouldn't it? (via the heat exchanger in the radiator) Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
dingah2 Crusty aviator Member 846 Member For: 20y 8m 6d Gender: Male Location: ACT Posted 02/04/07 08:22 AM Share Posted 02/04/07 08:22 AM No Tab - the other way round if anything at all.Dingah Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ninka Donating Members 1,850 Member For: 22y 2m 1d Gender: Male Location: Perth, WA Posted 02/04/07 08:53 AM Share Posted 02/04/07 08:53 AM No Tab - the other way round if anything at all.DingahSorry guys, you are both wrong A thermostat is a thermo-activated valve, which remains closed until a certain temperature is achieved, so whether you run a 'cool' or a 'warm' thermostat, has absolutely no influence on how quickly the engine or turbo warms up.Once the temperature is reached, the thermostat opens, and the water circulates through the radiator to keep the engine cooled. With a 'cool' thermostat, you will have more heatsink capacity, I.e. the difference between the operating temperature and when the engine will overheat, simply because there is a bigger differential temperature between operating and maximum temp.In an ideal world, the cooling capacity of the cooling system should be able to keep the engine temperature under control, but our cars produce more heat than the cooling system is capable of dissipating, and thus the engine temp. increases when driven hard, and this will make the engine less efficient (if it gets too hot).Hope this explains it! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now