did_4m41 Member 26 Member For: 17y 9m Posted 08/02/07 02:27 PM Share Posted 08/02/07 02:27 PM hi, just wondering 4 spd auto or 6 spd manual (modified or stock at same level), which one will be faster on rolling acceleration (not on race track - different story)?I think 6 spd ZF should be the fastest, so I don't include in this comparison. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
aiboart Member 665 Member For: 19y 9m 7d Posted 08/02/07 07:38 PM Share Posted 08/02/07 07:38 PM hi, just wondering 4 spd auto or 6 spd manual (modified or stock at same level), which one will be faster on rolling acceleration (not on race track - different story)?I think 6 spd ZF should be the fastest, so I don't include in this comparison.←Some perceptions - some data.If there is up shift involved, - the 4 speed auto is quicker. (G-Tech data.)If there is down shift involved,- using the speed auto's triptronic to signal downshift, the auto is much quicker.- allowing the 4 speed auto to figure out the downshift... hmm not sure about that - probably the manual.In single gear,- if you are above 2000 rpm and on boost, manual could be quicker- if you are below 2000 rpm or otherwise not on boost - auto is quickerRegards,aa Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
F6 UTE - Track Bound EVO III - Member 3,367 Member For: 19y 10m 7d Gender: Male Location: Strapped in and holding on Posted 09/02/07 12:03 AM Share Posted 09/02/07 12:03 AM Manual can be just as quick.. Too many factors, namely the driver and traction control..Also there will be too many guys who will want to compare 300rwkw auto to a 300rwkw manual.Auto makes more flywheel kw for the same rwkw figure, so unless everyone agrees on an engine figure there is no chance of finding you an answer..For mine, there should be ~ 280rwkw auto Vs 305rwkw manual to be fair. Some will argue that power at the wheels is what matters, and if they are the same, it's equal. This is wrong, as one car is plainy making more power.. I would also like to see an unmodified auto tranny run against a manual ( No firmed up shift points etc ) and see what the outcome is.This is one answer no-one will agree upon. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
F6 RAPID Formerly Turbo6 Donating Members 2,332 Member For: 21y 9m 15d Location: North Brisbane Posted 09/02/07 01:39 AM Share Posted 09/02/07 01:39 AM I am going with manual. Same power, a well driven manual should do an auto on rolling acceleration IMHO. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
RAPHOON Donating Members 1,776 Member For: 21y 3m 25d Posted 09/02/07 04:01 AM Share Posted 09/02/07 04:01 AM Agree with Shanus. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SCRIBR Yaris member Member 4,486 Member For: 18y 4m 1d Gender: Male Posted 09/02/07 05:09 AM Share Posted 09/02/07 05:09 AM manual is more fun... that's what counts Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
LUMO Donating Members 476 Member For: 17y 8m 8d Gender: Male Location: SYDNEY Posted 02/03/07 10:17 AM Share Posted 02/03/07 10:17 AM (edited) Manual can be just as quick.. Too many factors, namely the driver and traction control..Also there will be too many guys who will want to compare 300rwkw auto to a 300rwkw manual.Auto makes more flywheel kw for the same rwkw figure, so unless everyone agrees on an engine figure there is no chance of finding you an answer..For mine, there should be ~ 280rwkw auto Vs 305rwkw manual to be fair. Some will argue that power at the wheels is what matters, and if they are the same, it's equal. This is wrong, as one car is plainy making more power.. I would also like to see an unmodified auto tranny run against a manual ( No firmed up shift points etc ) and see what the outcome is.This is one answer no-one will agree upon.←ihave a manual ba xr6t and my mate has a auto ba xr6t both 02 model both stock my bro raced my mate and my 6t manual beat the auto by 4/5 cars this is rolling start at 70km/h maybe its the colour cause mine is red, that's why its quicker hehe remember red is fast Edited 02/03/07 10:18 AM by LUMO Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
O2STOCK Donating Members 607 Member For: 19y 1m 8d Location: Brisbane Posted 02/03/07 10:22 AM Share Posted 02/03/07 10:22 AM Agree with Shanus.←Im shocked both Pahpoon and Rapid going for the manual My money is on the Auto (Another shock ) Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Blonk Iconoclast Donating Members 4,330 Member For: 20y 25d Gender: Male Location: CH Posted 02/03/07 10:23 AM Share Posted 02/03/07 10:23 AM (edited) My guess is the F6 will be faster whatever it has got..!!Especially that yellow one from the northside that posted above!! Edited 02/03/07 10:24 AM by Blonk Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
O2STOCK Donating Members 607 Member For: 19y 1m 8d Location: Brisbane Posted 02/03/07 10:27 AM Share Posted 02/03/07 10:27 AM RaphoonWhy not test it out next month You V Me Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now